Insurance Claim Contacts

Claim Service
In the event of a claim, Princeton Insurance. strongly encourages clients to contact our office directly if the claim is being reported during working hours, which are: Monday through Friday, 9:00 am to 5:00 pm. If you want to report a claim and our office is closed, you can use the telephone number or Internet Website below for the insurance company you wish to contact. Please note that not all insurance companies have a 24 hour per day, 7 day per week claim reporting service.
If you’d like to reach any of the companies below, call their telephone number as listed or click on the company name link, when available, to visit their website for more information:

 

Company   Claim Phone #  Billing Phone #
American Commerce /MAPFRE 800-222-2114  800-222-2114
AmTrust of North America 866-272-9267 877-528-7878
AXIS 800-315-6090 888-654-3100
Chubb 800-252-4670 800-682-4822 #5
CNA Insurance Company 877-262-2727 800-262-4357
Employers Preferred Ins. Co.  800-232-3085 800-677-3252
Encompass Ins. 800-588-7400 800-262-9262
Farmers Mutual of Salem 800-498-0954 800-498-0954
Foremost Insurance 800-237-6136 800-527-3905
Guard Insurance Group  888-639-2567 800-673-2465 #9
Hartford Insurance Co. 800-327-3636 800-447-7649; option 2
Hartford Flood  888-888-2170  800-888-2170
Liberty Insurance  800-522-7152 866-290-2920
MetLife Auto & Home  800-854-6011 888-578-2663 # 1
Nationwide/ Harleysville Insurance – Commercial Lines 800-892-8877 888-547-8547
Nationwide/ Harleysville Insurance – Auto & Home  800-4336262 #5 800-433-6262 #1
NJ Skylands (National General) 866-279-7688; # 2  866-279-7688
Philadelphia Contributionship (PCIC) 800-269-1409  800-346-9229
Philadelphia Insurance Co.  800-765-9749 877-43807459
Progressive Commercial 800-444-4487  800-444-4487
Progressive Personal 800-274-4499  800-876-5581
Seneca 212-277-0236 212-277-3859 or 212-277-3952
Travelers – Commercial 800-832-7839  800-252-2268
Travelers – Home & Auto 800-252-4633 877-872-8651
USAssure  800-987-3373 800-800-3907 #2
USLI  888-875-5231 866-632-2003
Utica First   800-456-4556  800-456-4556
Utica National  315-235-6600 800-598-8422